Key Lime Yogurt Cake with Coconut


I’ve mentioned many times my adoration for anything lime-flavored. Whether it’s a pie, curd, cheesecake, beverage, or Sour Patch Kid, I’m going to love it. That’s all there is to it.

A friend of mine recently picked up an extra bag of key limes, and I definitely didn’t have a problem taking them off her hands (especially when the exchange happened during a brunch meeting that involved chorizo/jalapeno/egg/potato hash, thankyouverymuch).

This cake (or bread, if  you want to make it sound a little healthier) is inspired by Ina Garten’s lemon yogurt cake, which I’ve made a few times in various forms. While the cake is not exactly going to be featured in any healthy eating magazines any time soon, it is a less horrible for you than other things I could have made with the key limes. Plus, I adapted the recipe to make it a little lighter by using nonfat Greek yogurt, canola oil, reducing the sugar by a smidge, and eliminating the glaze altogether (personally I think it’s sweet enough with the citrus-sugar mixture that gets poured over the top).

I had some shredded coconut in my freezer, which was a welcome addition to this cake…a cake I freaking loved, by the way. The yogurt and lime syrup make this extremely moist, and the key limes have a tangy, robust flavor. Plus, toasted coconut is awesome. Always.


Key Lime Yogurt Cake with Coconut

26 thoughts on “Key Lime Yogurt Cake with Coconut

  1. “Less horrible for you” that’s usually what I end up going for. Because really…sometimes that cakes that ARE less horrible for you, just aren’t worth it. I’m a huge fan of all things lime AND all things coconut AND ESPECIALLY all things coconut/lime. This is pinned and bookmarked!

  2. Looks fantastic! I am not normally a big fan of lime, but would love to try this with the toasted coconut. And I agree, you can definitely pass this as bread (bread = healthier). Afterall, it is in the shape of a loaf, right? 🙂 I work the opposite way with my daughter – I tell her the healthier breads are cake! 🙂

  3. YEAHHH! Elly you have perfect timing, b/c I was just gifted a bag of key limes from my family friend! It’s like this scrumptious looking recipe was made for me. 🙂

  4. I bought some key limes on a quick sale rack a while ago and juiced them and froze the juice in ice cube trays and I’ve been trying to find things that aren’t key lime pie to make with it ever since then! So excited to try this because I, too, love lime flavored things. Yum!

  5. Thinking of making this is a birthday treat for my roommate- is it really more like a dessert or a bread? Any tips on making it more bread (breakfast)-like?

    1. Hi Elise. It could really go for either, though we mainly ate it as dessert. It’s sweeter than breakfast breads I’m used to (but, my breakfast breads usually are made with whole wheat and very little sugar). I think you’d be fine making it as is for a breakfast treat. If you wanted, you could substitute the coconut for something like raspberries (I love raspberries and lime together) or even make a streusel topping using some flour/butter/sugar/coconut.

  6. Pingback: Key Lime Pie Bars
    1. I used sweetened because that’s what I had on hand. The cake is pretty sweet, though, so I’m sure you’d be fine using unsweetened, too.

    1. Janet, I’ve done that in the original version before and it’s fine. I always prefer to use a little oil, though, to improve the texture, so I would do something like 1/4 cup oil and 1/3 cup applesauce (I tend to add a little more applesauce than a 1:1 switch).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *